Episode 46 - Becoming the Default Choice
Tom Burrell
April 25, 2025
Did someone forward this to you? If so, click to subscribe
Welcome to episode 46 of The Retention Blueprint!
Customers face overwhelming options across nearly every product and service category every day.
This "choice overload" creates decision fatigue.
Customers would rather stick with their choice.
And we can use that to our advantage in customer retention, as long as we do right by our customers.
This episode explores strategies for becoming your customers' "default choice" - the option they automatically select without considering alternatives.
Learn from the best at a fraction of the cost of live training.
Check out the Retention Coach CRM Marketing Strategy 2.0 course.
Over 1400 people have taken my CRM courses and training.
Inspired by learnings from Global Retention Leaders and 25 years consulting to some of the worlds biggest brands.
The Playbook for Tomorrow’s Voice-First Enterprises
Voice is the most natural, accessible interface—already used across 8.4 billion devices worldwide.
This guide reveals how leading enterprises are capitalizing on the shift to voice to reduce missed calls, improve customer access, and deploy scalable AI agents in just weeks.
From strategy to execution, learn how to turn voice into a competitive edge for your business.
📰 TOP STORY: How to become the default choice
In episode 13 of this newsletter, I discussed how a 5-10% improvement in retention can drive up to a 100% improvement in profit.
Ultimately, the goal of becoming the default choice is to maximise retention and drive growth.
To do this well requires deep customer understanding.
It requires you to optimise customer retention moments of truth.
It requires you to understand how customers realise value at a profound level.
If you are familiar with my work and the concept of a moment of truth or the customer value realisation process, you can skip these columns:
What are moments of truth? To drive meaningful improvements in retention, identify and optimise the key moments that determine whether customers stay or go in:
Improving retention by just 1-2% at each moment can compound to achieve that critical 5-10% overall improvement, which drives between a 25% and 100% improvement in profit. See episode 37 for more details. | Understanding how customers realise value The value realisation mindset represents a fundamental shift from believing your company delivers value to understanding that customers realise value by using your product or service. Instead of seeing your product as a gift bestowed upon customers, you recognise that value only exists when customers successfully use your offering to achieve their desired outcomes. See episode 33 for more details. |
So, you have optimised moments of truth? Now what?
To become the default choice, your product or service must be deeply integrated into your customers' routines and identities.
You can achieve this in three key ways:
1. Creating habits
Understanding the context in which customers use your product allows you to stimulate usage at the right moments. As behavioral science shows, humans often make decisions when prompted by environmental cues rather than pure motivation.
For example, Netflix might send a Thursday notification about new romantic comedies to customers who typically watch this genre on weekends. By making engagement simple and contextually relevant, you can trigger usage and create a habit.
2. Provide value beyond your core offer
Expanding your value proposition beyond your primary product helps cement your place in customers' lives:
Salesforce created the Ohana community, Dreamforce events, and an extensive learning ecosystem
Sephora has built a thriving customer community where consumers seek makeup advice, learn about events, and discover new products.
These extensions create additional touchpoints and reasons for customers to remain connected to your brand even when they're not actively using your core product.
3. Aligning with Customer Values
When your brand authentically connects with customers' beliefs and values, the relationship transcends transactional interactions:
Patagonia demonstrates environmental commitment through repair services and trade-in programs, knowing their customers realise value in nature.
This values alignment creates emotional bonds that are harder for competitors to break, even when they offer similar functional benefits.
How do you get to a stage where customers genuinely don't consider alternatives, even if the price for staying is higher than the price to leave?
If you make your customers feel valued and appreciated. They might stay.
If they feel loved, your brand will become their default choice.
1. Be on the Customer's Side
Orange Australia's rate plan health check program notified customers when they could save money by switching plans. This customer-first approach reduced churn by 57%, proving that looking after customer interests builds lasting loyalty.
2. Be Effortless
First Direct pioneered the Current Account Switch Service, removing a major barrier to adoption by handling everything for customers. When decision fatigue is high, simplicity becomes an invaluable differentiator.
3. Create Great Expectations
As Daniel Kahneman notes, "Memories are all we get to keep from our experience of living." Laundry Republic models its experience on luxury retail, using packaging that makes customers feel like they're receiving new clothes rather than laundered items back.
4. Solicit Feedback
Peloton responded to member questions about workout tracks by creating a "love" feature that allowed customers to sync favorite songs to their music platforms with one click. Listening and responding demonstrates your commitment to customer satisfaction.
5. Go The Extra Mile
Discover eliminated annual fees, removed rewards points breakage, provided 24/7 customer service, proactively warned about potential late fees, and monitored the dark web for card misuse.
6. Be Human
Paddy Power's distinctive social media presence creates a human connection through humor that perfectly matches their target audience. Being relatable humanises your brand in a crowded marketplace.
7. Delight
MasterCard's "Priceless Surprises" campaign offers random rewards to customers just for being customers. These unexpected positive experiences create memorable moments that strengthen the relationship.
Adopting these customer love principles in a way that is relevant to your brand and your business will help you become the default choice. But also the simple act of reducing choices and reducing friction can have a hugely positive impact on customer retention.
The T-Mobile Transformation: Reducing Choice Complexity
T-Mobile provides one of the best examples of how simplifying choices can dramatically improve customer relationships. Between 2012 and 2019, they transformed their business by:
Simplifying plans
Removing contracts
Making upgrades easier
Offering no-contract family plans
Including all taxes and fees in advertised prices
Streamlining their rewards program with no points breakage
These initiatives and deep focus on the moments that mattered to customers helped T-Mobile's NPS score rise from around 5 to almost 40, while its customer base nearly tripled from 35 million to 90 million. Millions of customers by default stayed with T-Mobile.
Final Thoughts
In a world of overwhelming choice, becoming the default isn’t about locking customers in - it’s about making staying feel like the obvious choice.
That takes more than a great product.
It takes deep empathy, smart habit-building, and relentless focus on the moments that matter most.
Brands like T-Mobile didn’t win by accident - they earned trust.
If you want to drive long-term growth, start by helping customers realise value, remove friction, and show up for them in the ways that matter to them.
Until next week,
Tom
P.S. What did you think of this episode? |
Do you need help with Customer Retention?
When you are ready, contact me to discuss consulting, my fast-track retention accelerator, courses, and training. Or if you are interested in sponsoring this newsletter, get in touch via [email protected]
Reply